Posted in 2017, Books, Discussion, June, My Friday Thoughts, Reviews

My Friday Thoughts – Should Book Reviews Talk About Spoilers?

Hello, people of the internet!

Whenever I look up reviews about books I am interested in, I tend to find two types of reviews: ones that talk about spoilers and ones that dare not even mention them. They are both equally good reviews, but it does leave me wondering this:

Should book reviews talk about spoilers?

Here is what I think!

There are pros and cons for both parties as talking about spoilers – such as plot twists – can alter, and even ruin, reading experiences for those who don’t want any spoilers (for example, I would have enjoyed Gone Girl more if it wasn’t spoilt for me), but there are cases where discussing spoilers is an essential part of a review, especially if it is a bad plot twist.

Whenever I write reviews for my blog, I decide whether or not it is important for me to talk about any spoilers in my review, especially if a spoiler actually spoilt (ha) the book in any way. I have read books in the past where I had spent so many hours getting to know the characters, following the plot and getting emotionally invested when something, like a plot twist, ruins the whole reading experience and even makes the whole experience turn sour. So when I review them, I warn of spoilers before I begin, and then discuss why that plot twist didn’t work – either because it came out of nowhere, it didn’t fit with the atmosphere of the book, etc. The last thing I would want to do is to potentially give other readers the chance to be as disappointed as I was just because I didn’t talk about spoilers.

However, if a spoiler is at least good, I don’t talk about them in such detail. I say that any twists and turns in the plot are well-written, for example. That way, the book isn’t spoilt, but the reader can be assured that the plot twist works.

Then again, plot twists themselves can be subjective. Take, for example, Daughter by Jane Shemilt. I was very angry at the plot twist and, since I personally wasn’t really into the story to begin with, felt the whole book was a waste of my time. Yet when I looked up other reviews of Daughter, there were readers that absolutely loved the book and loved the twist just as much!

So, I would in fact be risking ruining a book for someone else who would have liked the book just because I didn’t like it.

I don’t know if I’m over-thinking this, but reading is a very personal experience. The last thing I want to do is spoil a book for others who will enjoy a book, even though I personally disliked it.

Hence why we have spoiler warnings.

I do have spoiler warnings and I now aim to put them at the beginning of the review, so from there it is up to the reader to decide whether or not to continue. Also, what I aim to do with my reviews from now on is to start my reviews with how I feel about this book, then go on to explain why. It gives the reader an impression on what the whole atmosphere of the review is.

I hope that any of my readers would, along the lines anyway, think either this: “Oh, this book looks like something I would just love! Heck, this reviewer said she liked it! Imma go and read the review!” or this: “This book looks like something I would enjoy, but this reviewer didn’t like it. Hmm. I wonder why?” I am also happy with: “Oh, this review has spoilers. I’m not interested.”

I am still learning about how to review books, but this is what I personally think about including spoilers. Of course, other reviewers can review books however they want – this is just what I aim to do with my spoiler-filled book reviews:

  • If any spoilers are bad and affect your reading experience for the worst, feel free to explain why they were bad.
  • If any spoilers are good, feel free to not mention them and perhaps discuss why they work.
  • Spoiler warnings are very important, regardless if these spoilers are good or bad.
  • Start off your review with how you feel about the book, whether it be you liked it, loved it, hated it, etc., just so readers can start reading your review knowing what they’re getting themselves into – a bit like an essay if you will.

What do you think? Do you agree or disagree with me?

Thank you for reading!

Advertisements

Author:

Hello, people of the internet. My name's Gemma and this is my book blog! There will be reviews of books of any genre! There will also be book hauls, discussions and much more!

6 thoughts on “My Friday Thoughts – Should Book Reviews Talk About Spoilers?

  1. I’ve changed on this practice of writing reviews. Once you start avoiding spoilers, you have a fine line to toe before you and others get upset about the spoilers. Here are some of my personal rules and thoughts when I write reviews:
    -You can say you didn’t like the ending, but you can’t say what the ending was (unless it’s a classic, like Rome and Juliet).
    -I don’t think there’s anything wrong with saying how a character changed, but you have to be careful about explaining it.
    -Think about which spoilers would upset you to know beforehand.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Take it with a grain of salt. I worry that some things that might seem spoilery are actually okay. I want to convey what the story is about, but it can be such a hard balance.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I feel it’s important to not include spoilers as much as possible. Or, if you’re going to include them, give readers the chance to skip them if they want. I usually don’t discuss spoilers because I want my reviews to be accessible to everyone. If I do, I will use the aforementioned approach.
    I also avoid spoilery reviews at all costs as I, personally, can’t at all enjoy a book if I know certain key elements are going to happen. And I hate, hate, hate when people don’t have spoiler warnings in their reviews. I feel extremely misled and hurt.
    I, too, was spoiled for Gone Girl and I was soooo mad! Especially because it was the exact day I had decided to go and watch it. It just made me so angry, you have no idea.
    Great post 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re right – it is important to avoid spoilers as much as possible. I try to do that, but there have been books where the spoiler itself was badly written and ruined my reading experience, so in those reviews, I put in spoiler warnings before discussing why they didn’t work.
      Oh I hate it when reviews don’t have spoiler warnings! It is very unfair!
      I was livid when Gone Girl was spoilt for me. I had just bought the book as well and I didn’t read it until a lot later on.
      Thank you, I’m glad you liked it!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s